Is Les Misérables an Opera? Exploring the Boundaries of Musical Theatre
When discussing the nature of Les Misérables, one might wonder: is it an opera? The question itself opens up a fascinating dialogue about the boundaries between opera and musical theatre. While Les Misérables is often categorized as a musical, its grandeur, emotional depth, and sweeping score have led some to argue that it shares more in common with opera than with traditional Broadway fare. This article delves into the characteristics of Les Misérables, compares it to both opera and musical theatre, and explores why this distinction matters.
The Case for Les Misérables as an Opera
At first glance, Les Misérables possesses many qualities typically associated with opera. Its score, composed by Claude-Michel Schönberg, is through-composed, meaning there is little to no spoken dialogue. The story is conveyed almost entirely through music, a hallmark of operatic tradition. The themes of Les Misérables—love, sacrifice, revolution, and redemption—are also staples of opera, which often explores grand, universal human experiences.
The vocal demands of Les Misérables further blur the line between musical theatre and opera. Roles like Jean Valjean and Javert require singers with exceptional range, power, and emotional expressiveness, qualities often associated with operatic performers. The famous aria “Bring Him Home,” sung by Valjean, is a prime example of a piece that could easily fit into an operatic repertoire, demanding both technical skill and deep emotional resonance.
Moreover, the scale of Les Misérables is operatic in nature. The production features a large ensemble, intricate set designs, and a sweeping orchestral score. The story spans decades and encompasses a wide array of characters, much like many operas that aim to tell epic tales.
The Case for Les Misérables as a Musical
On the other hand, Les Misérables is firmly rooted in the tradition of musical theatre. It originated in France as a concept album before being adapted into a stage musical by Alain Boublil and Jean-Marc Natel. The show made its way to London’s West End and later to Broadway, where it became one of the longest-running musicals in history. Its commercial success and widespread popularity are hallmarks of musical theatre rather than opera.
Musical theatre often prioritizes accessibility, and Les Misérables is no exception. While the score is complex, it is designed to be approachable for a broad audience. The melodies are memorable, and the lyrics, though poetic, are in English (or the language of the production), making the story easier to follow than many operas, which are often performed in their original languages with supertitles.
Additionally, the structure of Les Misérables aligns more closely with musical theatre. While it lacks spoken dialogue, it includes recitative-like passages that move the plot forward, a technique common in musicals. The show also features ensemble numbers, such as “One Day More,” which are more characteristic of musical theatre than opera.
Why the Distinction Matters
The debate over whether Les Misérables is an opera or a musical is more than just an academic exercise. It speaks to the evolving nature of both genres and how they intersect. Opera has traditionally been seen as high art, often inaccessible to the general public due to its complexity and language barriers. Musical theatre, by contrast, is often viewed as more populist, designed to entertain and engage a wide audience.
Les Misérables challenges these distinctions by blending elements of both genres. Its success demonstrates that audiences are willing to embrace works that combine the emotional depth and musical sophistication of opera with the accessibility and storytelling of musical theatre. This fusion has paved the way for other hybrid works, such as The Phantom of the Opera and Miss Saigon, which similarly blur the lines between the two forms.
Conclusion
So, is Les Misérables an opera? The answer depends on how one defines the boundaries between opera and musical theatre. While it shares many characteristics with opera—its through-composed score, vocal demands, and epic scope—it is ultimately a product of the musical theatre tradition. What makes Les Misérables truly remarkable is its ability to transcend these categories, offering a work that is both artistically profound and widely accessible. Whether you call it an opera or a musical, there is no denying its enduring impact on the world of performing arts.
Related Questions
-
What are the key differences between opera and musical theatre?
Opera is typically through-composed with little to no spoken dialogue, often performed in foreign languages, and emphasizes vocal prowess. Musical theatre includes spoken dialogue, is usually performed in the local language, and balances singing with acting and dancing. -
Why is Les Misérables considered a groundbreaking work?
Les Misérables broke new ground by combining the emotional and musical complexity of opera with the accessibility and storytelling of musical theatre, appealing to a broad audience and influencing future productions. -
Can a work be both an opera and a musical?
While the terms are often used to categorize works, some productions, like Les Misérables, blur the lines between the two, incorporating elements of both genres. -
What role does the audience play in defining a work as an opera or a musical?
Audience expectations and cultural context play a significant role. Works that are performed in opera houses and attract opera enthusiasts may be labeled as operas, while those in commercial theatres are often seen as musicals. -
How has Les Misérables influenced modern musical theatre?
Les Misérables has inspired a wave of epic, through-composed musicals that tackle serious themes and feature complex scores, pushing the boundaries of what musical theatre can achieve.